Who Will Shine in 2025? A Look at AFL Teams’ Predicted Best Lineups

The 2025 AFL season promises excitement with a mix of fresh talent, strategic trades, and reshuffled lineups across all teams. As the offseason player movements settle, AFL enthusiasts are eager to see how their favorite clubs shape up for the upcoming season. Here’s an in-depth look at projected lineups for 2025, showcasing the players expected to make an impact and those who might face stiff competition to retain their spots.

Adelaide Crows: Speed and Agility in the Midfield

The Adelaide Crows’ lineup for 2025 will see a more dynamic midfield, thanks to key additions like Sid Draper and James Peatling. Draper, a promising draftee, brings agility and speed, while Peatling’s recruitment bolsters the engine room led by Jordan Dawson and Matt Crouch. With Izak Rankine expected to play a more on-ball role, Adelaide’s midfield depth is formidable. However, this improvement comes at a cost, as players like Sam Berry and Hugh Bond may struggle to make the starting 22. Defensively, Isaac Cumming’s inclusion strengthens the backline, while emerging talents like Dan Curtin and Wayne Milera could add versatility.

Brisbane Lions: An Overflow of Talent

The Lions enter 2025 with a wealth of options, making it challenging to finalize their best lineup. Returning stars like Keidean Coleman and Levi Ashcroft add depth to an already strong squad. The departure of Joe Daniher leaves a gap in the forward line, but young talents like Henry Smith offer hope as a dual forward and ruck option. Veterans like Dayne Zorko and Harris Andrews anchor the team, while recruit Tom Doedee provides defensive stability. At full strength, Brisbane has an enviable mix of youth and experience, though decisions on final inclusions remain difficult.

Carlton Blues: Defensive Reinforcements and Rising Stars

Carlton’s offseason acquisitions, including Nick Haynes and draftee Jagga Smith, address key defensive needs. Smith, a standout prospect, is poised for a round-one debut, while Haynes adds reliability to the backline. The midfield remains robust with Patrick Cripps and Sam Walsh leading the charge. Meanwhile, Jesse Motlop’s anticipated growth could make him a crucial part of the forward line. Depth options like Corey Durdin and Alex Cincotta ensure healthy competition, and promising players such as Ashton Moir are likely to earn senior opportunities during the season.

Collingwood Magpies: Versatility and Experience

Collingwood’s backline sees significant upgrades with the addition of Dan Houston and Harry Perryman, both of whom offer flexibility and skill. The team remains reliant on veteran stars like Steele Sidebottom and Scott Pendlebury to mentor emerging players. Tim Membrey strengthens the forward line alongside Jamie Elliott and Brody Mihocek. With talent pushing for opportunities, players like Tom Mitchell and Fin Macrae may face stiff competition for regular spots. Collingwood’s blend of experience and fresh talent ensures a competitive edge in 2025.

Essendon Bombers: Youthful Energy and Strategic Shuffles

Essendon has embraced youth, with draftee Isaac Kako set to debut in the forward line. The team’s attack will also rely heavily on Nate Caddy, who steps into a lead role following Jake Stringer’s departure. The midfield welcomes new recruit Xavier Duursma, with hopes pinned on his wing play. The Bombers face key decisions regarding their defensive structure, with Zach Reid’s fitness being pivotal. Veteran Todd Goldstein’s role alongside Sam Draper in the ruck remains a topic of debate. Essendon’s lineup reflects a balance of youthful promise and experienced leadership.

Fremantle Dockers: Balancing Veterans and New Talent

Fremantle faces tough calls in 2025, with club legends Nat Fyfe and Michael Walters potentially shifting into substitute roles. The arrival of star recruit Shai Bolton adds firepower to the forward line, while fourth-year midfielder Neil Erasmus is pushing for regular midfield minutes. The Dockers are looking to refine their backline and midfield dynamics, ensuring they remain competitive in a challenging league. Emerging stars like Jye Amiss and Luke Jackson further highlight Fremantle’s bright future.

A Season of Transformation

The 2025 AFL season is set to showcase evolving strategies, bold recruitment moves, and the rise of new stars across all clubs. While teams aim to field their best lineups, the depth and competition for spots underline the league’s growing talent pool. Fans can look forward to thrilling matchups, with seasoned veterans and ambitious newcomers striving to make their mark.